The Best Documentary Wedding Videographers in Verona, NY

The Best Documentary Wedding Videographers in Verona, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


28 Wedding Videographers in Verona, NY

Documentary
Kip Jackson Photography and Videography 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $2,100
  • Serves Verona, NY

New York certified Teacher who started my own Videography Company to help others remember their Big Day through documenting it the best I can. Through working with industry leading people and equipment over the last 5 years my process has helped me serve over 80 couples to this day.

Kip was recommended to us from a friend and we could not have been happier!! He reached out initially to discuss what we wanted our video focused on- a love story of the day, more of the party etc. Working with Kip the day of the wedding was so much fun (and stress free!!). He was with us the whole night and didn't miss a moment. He really took the time to create a beautiful film for us to have as a memory of the day. Watching our video for the first time, he captured the day perfectly. We loved having Kip be apart of our day!!
Tristan M., 3 years ago
Toast Weddings 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $2,500
  • Serves Verona, NY

We've been honored to create wedding films for hundreds of incredible couples. Each one of their stories is distinctive and we pride ourselves on creating moving films that artistically convey those love stories. We believe your wedding is not just about one day. It’s about your story leading up to that day and the stories that will come after. Our wedding videos bring your day to life – allowing the two of you to relive every laugh, every tear, and every moment that went by in a flash. Your loved ones will thank you for allowing your celebration to serve as a legacy of family history for generations to come.

I am so thrilled we went with Toast photography and videography for our wedding! From the communication prior, to the day of, the team was very professional and easy to reach. They did such an amazing job, working their tails off to capture every detail of our big day. Both our photographer & videographer felt like friends by the end of the night. The photos we received are wonderful, so full of love, and she made us look like super models! The moment my husband and I started watching our highlight wedding video we were in tears of joy. It took us right back to our wedding day! If you’re on the fence about getting videography & photos, take this as your sign to do it, and to hire Toast!
Julianna T., 2 months ago
Quick responder
ALENKA FILMS 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $3,000
  • Serves Verona, NY

NOW BOOKING 2026!! Hi, I'm Alëna! Please INQUIRE ON MY WEBSITE OR VIA EMAIL ONLY (way faster than zola). I’ve been making videos for over 10 years now. I believe in sucking the joy out of life and documenting it. I love capturing different traditions & religions AND of course documenting your love or breaking the dance floor are my literal favs! With Alenka Films you know exactly who you're getting as your filmmaker and story teller (not an outsourced stranger, just me). Consistent delivery of your vision every time! If you're ready for an amazing celebration, shoot me a dm! :) Please check out my IG / Youtube for moreee!

Awarded Best of Zola
Incredible. Well worth it. Phenomenal video edits and raw footage. Top of the line professional, does not disappoint!!
Savannah S., a year ago
Quick responder
Mist + Moss 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $6,500
  • Serves Verona, NY

Hi, I'm Chad. My goal is to create something captivating that you can cherish for a lifetime, while at the same time giving you and your guests an amazing experience. My films are tailored to you, authentic to your story and your wedding.

Awarded Best of Zola
I don’t think there are enough words in the English language to perfectly describe how amazing Mist and Moss is but, I’ll try my best. My husband and I chose Mist and Moss based on a recommendation from our photographer and we couldn’t be more grateful for that recommendation. Chad’s portfolio was initially what drew us in but when we had a video call, it was a done deal. He asked the most poignant, heartwarming questions that reminded us how extraordinary it is to find the one you love and share it with your loved ones. The true meaning of wedding. On the day of our wedding Chad arrived with the calmest demeanor which completely zapped all our nerves. Everything was so easy and fluid. He was present for all the right moments and gave us space when we needed it. The beauty of it all is that we can barely remember seeing him during our ceremony and reception. I swear he has ninja like skills; always around but never in sight. He brought so much warmth to a day that was bursting with love. It was the exact energy we needed. When we received our videos… just, wow. We couldn’t wait to share them with our loved ones. Chad and his wife PERFECTLY captured the beauty and feeling of the day in its entirety. I don’t know how he managed to bottle up the feeling of that day but every time we watch our wedding video, we are immediately taken back in time… to our favorite day. The professionalism, care, artistry, and ability to perfectly capture a moment in time is where Chad and his team shines. We would hire him again in a heartbeat! Thank you for giving us the ability to relive our more cherished day over and over again!
Whitney B., a year ago
Quick responder
Weddings by LDF 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Serves Verona, NY
  • Offer

Weddings by LDF specializes in documentary wedding films that place an emphasis on real, authentic moments. By preserving natural tones you're getting a film that looks classic and true to life. Owner Ray Lewis has been in business for more than nine years. He and his team film more than 300 love stories per year, and each celebration moves and inspires them all over again. Ray and his team don’t just enjoy what they do; they feel blessed to share in something truly extraordinary. They love making connections with their clients and witnessing moments that touch the heart.

Awarded Best of Zola
LDF films is AMAZING! They are so professional and so friendly. This was a part of the wedding day I did not need to worry about because Ray and his team had everything flowing great! I could not recommend them more!
Mary Fogleman N., 2 years ago
Dream Space Weddings 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $3,500
  • Serves Verona, NY

Dream Space Weddings is a wedding and elopement videography & photography company based in New York. We are a small team of artists dedicated to creating the greatest wedding videos out there, and we also make sure to support our couples along their wedding journey in every way. Making sure your venue is perfect, connecting other vendors, keeping timeline smooth... we bring not just our art, but our experience to make your wedding perfect.

Awarded Best of Zola
Tyler's immense passion and intoxicating enthusiasm for filming weddings and capturing the unique love story behind each of his couples, paired with his warm, friendly demeanor, and impeccable professionalism make him an ideal choice when it comes to deciding on a filmmaker for your wedding. Tyler takes the time to truly get to know his couples and is constantly keeping his eye out for all of the intimate and authentic moments that take place throughout your special day. Tyler also brings a vast wealth of knowledge and skills that truly elevate his films. Despite being a filmmaker myself, I'm blown away by his ability to document not only all of the major moments from each of the weddings that he has captured, but also all of the little moments that make them all unique. Tyler really goes the extra mile to make each of his wedding films feel like it's own, one-of-a-kind movie that his couples will cherish for a lifetime. On top of everything else, Tyler is so much fun to be around and is genuinely such a contentious, thoughtful person. Remember, you are going to spend your entire wedding day with the person you hire to capture your wedding/elopement. So book Tyler with Dream Space Weddings, you will be so glad you did!
Carmen C., 11 days ago
Quick responder
lovebyanthony 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $3,000
  • Serves Verona, NY

Hi I’m Anthony! I’ve had a camera in my hands since I was 14 - what started as a teenage curiosity quickly grew into a lifelong passion for storytelling. Over the years, I’ve taught myself everything I know about filmmaking, and after filming my first wedding five years ago, I knew I had found my purpose. There’s something truly special about capturing the emotion, laughter, and small, unspoken moments that make a wedding day unforgettable. It’s an honor every single time I get to help couples preserve that feeling forever

Anthony captured ALL of our favorite moments during our wedding. He was very attentive and even helped guide us during certain moments when taking photos. I have recommended him to many friends and they all love him and his work!!
Michael S., 9 months ago
Quick responder
Hitched & Highlighted - Video Lite & Content Creation 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Serves Verona, NY
  • Offer

Hi there! We're Justin + Nicole, Marine Corps Veteran + the owners/operators of HH - LOCAL to you with a TINY team, using local video vendors as you would. With 600+ 5-star reviews, our goal is to SAVE you money on wedding video with Video Lite. We formed HH in 2023 after struggling to find an affordable wedding video option for our wedding - so much that we went without :( Now we run our own small business catering to just that! Your package includes: -Ceremony recording -Highlight reel -RAW videos -RAW photos -Payment plans -Photo/video bundles -No fees! *See all pricing, availability, and book directly online!*

Awarded Best of Zola
As a photographer that has worked along side one of Hitched & Highlighted creators, I have nothing but praise to share! Not only was the creator professional and easy to work with, but they also were creative and proactive when it came to capturing the couples events throughout the day. We worked as a cohesive team to capture the day flawlessly for the couple! Definitely will always recommend for other couples!
Chelsea, 5 months ago
Quick responder
Wedding Weekender 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $459
  • Serves Verona, NY

Wedding Weekender is redefining wedding video with a more authentic, accessible way to capture your celebration. We send camcorders for your friends and family to film candid moments across your wedding weekend — from getting ready to the dance floor and everything in between. Afterward, our editing team shapes that footage into a thoughtful, nostalgic wedding video that feels true to your celebrations. We believe meaningful wedding video should feel personal, accessible, and rooted in real moments.

Simply OBSESSED. I worked with the Wedding Weekender for my bachelorette and wedding and both times was SO happy with the result. The team is prompt and communicative, answering our questions before and quick to provide our footage afterward. It was such a bonus to get all the raw footage in addition to the final video - my husband and I watched clips every night on our honeymoon, the best way to reminisce!! I loved having content that was from the POV of my guests, it makes you feel like you’re right back in the middle of things. Lastly, this was such a cost effective solution when you already have so many other things to worry about. Video was the first thing we cut from our budget, but with this we were able to have it all. I couldn’t recommend them more!!!
Molly H., 25 days ago
GemHidden gem
Fallingwater Films 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $3,900
  • Serves Verona, NY

We offer a unique style of wedding documentary. Imagine handing your good friend a camcorder at your wedding. They know exactly what to capture, and how to capture it. That's because they know you so well! We emulate this, but bring years of documentary film, and wedding content creation experience. It's our goal to help you hold onto your special day, because from what we've heard, it passes in a flash. Let's tell your story together.

Fallingwater Films was the perfect choice for our wedding videography. From our first interaction, Ian was reliable, trustworthy, and truly cared about making our day special. The final video he created is absolutely amazing - it beautifully captured all the meaningful moments and brought our love story to life in a way that exceeded our expectations. The video is a stunning keepsake that we'll cherish forever. We can't wait to share it with our guests on our big day. Fallingwater Films' incredible work and dedication made our wedding day even more perfect.
Lara K., 2 months ago
Quick responder
Memories In The Making Video Productions 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $900
  • Serves Verona, NY

I love what I do! I have been a professional videographer and photographer for over 25 years. I have an excellent reputation for being professional and easy to work with. My style is discrete documentary.

Memories In The Making Video Productions was a pleasure to work with for our wedding videography. From our first interaction, Dale was genuine, clear, and kind, putting us at ease throughout the planning process. On the day of the wedding, Dale was diligent, thoughtful, and captured the unique moments of our special day in a truly special way. We would highly recommend Memories In The Making Video Productions to any couple looking for an exceptional wedding videography experience.
Sarah K., 7 months ago
Quick responder
Jones Media | Videography 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Serves Verona, NY

Jones Media is a wedding photography and videography company that is dedicated to capturing the love, emotion, and joy of your special day. Founded by a team of passionate and talented photographers and videographers, Jones Media strives to deliver exceptional quality and service to every couple they work with. With years of experience in the wedding industry, the team at Jones Media understands the importance of capturing the intimate moments that make your day unique.

We could not be happier with our wedding video. From start to finish, our videographer was professional, calm, and an absolute joy to work with on such a big day. They made us feel comfortable in front of the camera and somehow captured every meaningful moment without ever feeling intrusive. The final video completely exceeded our expectations — beautifully edited, emotional, and so us. It didn’t just document the day, it captured how it felt. We’ve watched it more times than we can count! If you’re on the fence about hiring a wedding videographer, do it — and if you’re choosing one, we cannot recommend them highly enough. This is something we’ll cherish forever.
Madison M., 20 days ago
Quick responder
Humblebee Wedding Films 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $3,996
  • Serves Verona, NY for additional fees
  • Offer

Hello couples and congrats on your engagement! My name is Mike and I am the founder of Humblebee Wedding Films. We love filming with emotion which is why weddings are one of our most favorite live events to document. We have been filmmakers for many years but just started filming weddings in 2021. From our very first wedding we knew that this was going to be our calling. I tell all my couples, if I am getting teary-eyed while editing your wedding film...I know I'm doing it right! I can't wait to talk with you about how we can make magic together. P.S. We are a firm believer in equality and inclusion. Love is love!

Awarded Best of Zola
Mike and the team at Humblebee were absolutely amazing!! We got so lucky finding them for our wedding videography. Mike was always super responsive and the final videos were amazing. My husband and I were in tears watching it!
Stefanie C., a year ago
Quick responder
Perfect Cadence Events 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $2,500
  • Serves Verona, NY for additional fees

Perfect Cadence Events offers an unobtrusive style of videography that provides full coverage of your days events while you enjoy the company of family and friends. We strive to capture even the small, genuine moments to be enjoyed for years to come. Options include highlight (5-10 minute), full-length (1-2hr) and short feature (30 minute) edit profiles. Ask about drone coverage in your area!

Awarded Best of Zola
We hired Perfect Cadence Events for our wedding in June 2024 for videography and DJ and we are so glad we did. Logan, the owner, was our videographer and he was so professional, kind, and great to work with. He is super quick with communication, answered all of our questions, and he made sure to ask the right questions to capture our wedding day the way we wanted. On our wedding day, he gave us some advice and helped calm our nerves, he was so friendly. We did a ceremony video and a highlights reel and added on toasts. They were all so great and I can't wait to watch them every year on our anniversary. A lot of my friends told us they wished they had a videographer at their wedding and I can see why. It will be so great to have these memories to watch over and over. Then we had Mike as our DJ and he was great to work with. We had a couple of phone calls and they use an online platform to ask you questions and to put in must play songs, etc and it was awesome to have because it made sure we didn't forget anything and that we had everything we wanted. I highly recommend Perfect Cadence!
Sara, a year ago
TrendlineTrending
Purple Thistle Films 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Serves Verona, NY for additional fees

Hi! I am a wedding filmmaker and award winning documentary filmmaker, shooting digital and Super 8 film. I make digital long format documentary wedding films, digital highlight films with 1 song and no day of audio and Super 8 highlight films. My availability is in the FAQ page of my website. I consider wedding days exciting opportunities to step into communities and make something beautiful that reflects who people are and their experience. Get in touch if you are looking for someone with great instincts who can encapsulate your day authentically, reflecting the spontaneity of the moment. Love all love.

Awarded Best of Zola
Amanda was the perfect pick for our wedding! She was so nice throughout the day and even took some stunning drone shots before the event even started! We loved our final film so much.
Belinda, a year ago
KURO Creative House - Wedding Photo & Video 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Serves Verona, NY for additional fees

KURO Creative House (formerly Hereafter Films) is a wedding production house of talented videographers & photographers serving Central Texas & the Pacific Northwest. Throw out the stress of formulaic & performative weddings. We want you to have an experience-driven, true-to-you celebration with cohesive & creative wedding photography & videography to remember it all. When your veil flies in your face, when you wipe your tears on your sleeve, when you dance until you can't breathe, that's where we thrive.

Do you want a cinematic piece of art to remember your wedding day? Sharayah and Ryan are my go-to, number one recommended videographers. Sure, on the vendor side they are a dream to work with, but on the client side you can have a piece of mind knowing that your wedding will be thoughtfully and artistically documented by two of the most loving, fun, and talented duo. I'm already married but cannot wait to hire Hereafter for a vow renewal someday. They are A++
Gloria Goode, 5 years ago
Mawaddah Productions 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $5,700
  • Serves Verona, NY for additional fees

Mawaddah Productions a women-owned videography company who has been dedicated to artistic and authentic storytelling worldwide for years. Specializing in wedding cinematography, Mawaddah Productions delicately crafts documentary heirloom films for romantics.

Awarded Best of Zola
We are not joking when we say that we hired Saja from Mawaddah productions at 8:30 am on our wedding day after realizing that we almost made one of the biggest mistakes by not having a videographer. And this was definitely the BEST decision we made. We were amazed that Saja not only managed to travel two hours from Boston to Alstead New Hampshire with a last minute notice for the job, but also exceeded our expectations by capturing all these priceless and unforgettable moments with little to no preparation other than a timeline flyer a few hours beforehand. The cinematography is insane: she films so beautifully and candidly, and her attention to details is unparalleled. Through her art and vision, she was able to translate this day which needless to say, went by overwhelmingly fast, into such a beautiful beautiful endless everlasting memory that we can now forever replay. We ABSOLUTELY ADOREDDDD the teaser, the short wedding film and the feature film. We shared it with our entire families and friends and they are completely in love. The short wedding film is on constant repeat. We could not thank her and recommend her enough for her incredible work and talent.
Lea Hajjar E., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Williams Event Services 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves Verona, NY for additional fees

Conner Williams specializes in wedding videography, blending creativity and technical expertise to craft films that beautifully capture each couple’s unique love story. With a background in TV production and content creation, he brings a professional touch to every project. Conner’s personal approach ensures your wedding day is documented with care, creating timeless memories to cherish forever. Having completed plenty of weddings, his experience and dedication make him a trusted choice for preserving life’s most meaningful moments.

Awarded Best of Zola
We used Conner for our wedding on May 3, 2025. We were looking for a DJ and our photographer who had worked with him multiple times had recommended him…. Fast forward we found out he also did videography and we booked him for both- and we are so glad we did! He was so amazing, along with our photographer, they worked together so well and made sure we stayed on schedule and got all the moments captured we wanted. We almost didn’t go with videography but I’m so glad we decided to! He did such an amazing job with both the video and DJ. If we could do the day again, we would 100% have him again! He is so great to work with and so professional, I would recommend him to everyone! Thank you so much Conner for capturing the best day of our lives, the video was even better than we ever imagined. I hope we have the chance to work with you again in the future for another event. THANK YOU!!!!
Libby B., 8 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Modern Flora Wedding Films 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $2,800
  • Serves Verona, NY for additional fees

We're a collective of filmmakers and artists that specialize in wedding stories. Relive the magic of your wedding day with cinematic, storytelling-driven films. We specialize in creating high-energy, emotive highlights and full-feature films that showcase the candid, authentic moments you missed. From the cinematic aerial shots to the intimate vows, our expert team brings the art of film to your wedding. Discover why couples choose Modern Flora Wedding Films to turn their best day into a cinematic masterpiece.

Working with Modern Flora Wedding Films was a truly wonderful experience. From our first conversation, they were fun, professional, kind, and understanding - making the entire process feel easy and stress-free. The quality of their work was excellent, providing great value and delivered quickly. They navigated some difficult situations on our wedding day with ease, and even helped fix my bouquet when it started to fall apart. I would highly recommend Modern Flora Wedding Films to any couple looking for an exceptional wedding videography team.
Steadman, 16 days ago
Quick responder
HWVP Weddings 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $3,000
  • Serves Verona, NY for additional fees

Welcome! I'm Hayden, a wedding videographer based in Knoxville, TN. We love serving couples all across the south and nationwide. Over the past five years, I've had the privilege of documenting over 100 weddings across East Tennessee, South Carolina, North Carolina, Georgia, and Montana. Each one has been a unique experience, filled with unforgettable moments and heartfelt stories. Wherever your wedding takes you we are here to capture every real moment and create lasting memories for you to cherish.

I cannot recommend Hayden enough. We met him a year and a half before our wedding and recommended him to all of our friends just based on his past work being so amazing. He captured every single moment perfectly for our wedding day and missed nothing. He was very professional and had the best personality and clicked with all the other vendors! Our video was everything we dreamed of and more, you need him at your wedding!!!!!
Abby K., 4 years ago
GemHidden gem
Dianna Nguyen Films 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $4,950
  • Serves Verona, NY for additional fees

When inviting me in to tell a part of your story, you are letting me into your relationship. No matter the session, elopement, or wedding, I will capture without reserve everything from the smallest details to the greatest landscape; so when you return to this story you will feel everything. From the last light on the horizon to the messy and playful love, your film will hold memories, not just videos.

Awarded Best of Zola
I recommend Dianna to literally every single couple that books a photography package with me— if you’ve inquired with me, you’ve heard of her! She is the absolute best person to work with. She is incredibly professional, creative, and kind. We have so much fun working weddings together and I cannot wait to work more in the future. Seriously couldn’t recommend her enough!
Haley Wilde, 4 years ago
TrendlineTrending
Lollie Wedding Films 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $1,950
  • Serves Verona, NY for additional fees
  • Offer

Hi! We're Lola & Hollie, hence Lollie! We are a wife-wife wedding videography duo based in Boston. Our approach is based in passion, love and creativity. We always shoot with a two videographer team and two or more HD cameras to ensure a special moment is never missed. When you choose to work with us, you're making an investment in preserving your memories for years to come.

10/10 - would recommend. We had a large wedding planned and then COVID hit. We rescheduled the big event but continued with our wedding and small reception for 20 close family members. Lole and Hollie were amazing. They explained all the package options and worked with us when we changed our plans. They were super easy to get along with and clearly know what they are talking about. I was a bit overwhelmed about what I wanted but they were patient. I probably will never watch my entire wedding but they made us an awesome "teaser" which I love and it really captured the day. They truly saved our wedding because our photographer was awful. She double booked and didn't get any of the shots. When we mentioned this to Lola and Hollie they were able to get us some screen shots of their video of important moments (first kiss, walking out the church) - ya know kinda a big deal.... They really saved us and I would recommend them to anyone and everyone.
Alexis & L., 3 years ago
Quick responder
Food & Cake Wedding Films 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $3,000
  • Serves Verona, NY for additional fees

HEYYY! *waves hands* We are Leandra & Clinton Cunanan, owners and lead videographers of Food & Cake Wedding Films. We are huge advocates for doing exactly what you want on your wedding day. We had the most epic wedding of all time (ask us about it!), but we didn't hire a videographer. And now this why we do what we do. It's the best feeling knowing each one of our couples will be able to relive their wedding day for the rest of their lives. We didn't have that, and now we get to give that to you!

I am so blown away by not only the quality of Clint and Leandra's work as videographers, but also what wonderful people they are! Not even halfway through our first zoom with them to talk about what packages they offer and our vision for the day I knew they were the perfect fit for us! Being with them on the wedding day felt like hanging out with old friends, they were amazing at blending in to the crowd to capture candid moments while also giving us prompts that created some of our favorite memories of the day. They worked so well with our other vendors and I don't think our day would have been complete without them. They are masters at what they do, and also the perfect people to have during a busy and, at times, stressful day (Leandra was able to bussle my dress when no one else could get the loop on the buttons AND snagged me some appetizers when I was resting my feet after the receiving line, she was a lifesaver!) My husband and I both teared up watching our trailer and highlight reel, and then happy cried getting to see our whole ceremony, private vows, speeches, and first dances. I know this is footage we’ll be so happy to look back on in the years to come, not just of my husband and I but of our whole families as well! I'm so happy we found Food Cake, you will not regret hiring this fantastic couple!
Megan + T., 2 years ago
New
Towering Pines Productions 

5.0

  • Documentary style
  • Starts at $6,500
  • Serves Verona, NY for additional fees

Were Sam & Pat! We bring 15+ years of experience from working on documentary and commercial projects for The Smithsonian, New York Times, Meta, Google and others; to create wedding films that resonate. Our passion lies in observing and capturing the organic flow of your wedding day. We work discreetly, allowing your story to unfold naturally, while also employing cinematic techniques to elevate the visual narrative. The result is a film that feels honest, deeply personal, and beautifully crafted. We cherish the opportunity to capture love in all its forms and are dedicated to telling the story of your wedding day, no matter the size.

We just finished filming our interview and we could not be more excited to film our wedding. Who else is doing genuine interviews!? I can't wait for the final film. Working with Pat and Sam has been super fun and stress free. You can just feel that they not only know what they are doing but they work so well together, laughing and joking and made us feel so at ease. I hate being on camera or public speaking in general, but instantly forgot we were filming.
Thomas B., 21 days ago

About wedding videographers in Verona, NY

What types of videographers are in Verona, NY?

What other Verona vendors will I need?

What other videographers are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?